British prime minister Benjamin Disraeli who is famously credited with the phrase: "There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics" but the expression has been around almost as long as the word statistics (first coined in 1749 for those wondering). Clearly Trump was asleep or chasing underage girls in that part of the history curriculum.
But what of the situation for USA today? We should all be VERY afraid. Why?
1. He simply does not understand complexity—and refuses anyone who does
Donald Trump’s reaction to the July 2025 jobs report—merely 73,000 new jobs added—was a blunt refusal of nuance. When figures didn’t flatter him, he declared them “RIGGED,” immediately firing Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Commissioner Erika McEntarfer. That kind of reflex betrays an inability—or unwillingness—to engage with technical detail .
Rather than accept expert revisions—standard statistical updates that downgraded May and June by 258,000 jobs in total—Trump scapegoated the messengers .
2. Trusted dissenters are branded liars; others are found “stupid”
The administration systematically removes anyone who questions or refines the narrative. McEntarfer was dismissed after job numbers disappointed him. No evidence of manipulation, yet she was replaced instantly .
Across statistical agencies—from the Bureau of Economic Analysis to USDA’s Economic Research Service—the Trump administration slashed budgets, shuttered datasets, and triggered mass resignations—not because of incompetence, but because independent analysis contradicted his agenda .
3. Cuts to experts and source data = manufactured ignorance
Over 275,000 federal workers have been laid off under the second Trump administration, including dozens of probationary employees in statistical units like BLS, Census, NIH, EPA, NOAA, and USDA research arms .
These broad cuts cripple statistical capacity, delay or cancel critical reports, and make it impossible to have reliable data—intentionally or not .
4. The “jobs report” fiasco is entirely of his making
When job growth fell to 73,000 in July—far below expectations of 115,000—Trump lashed out, refusing to accept standard downward revisions as routine. Instead, he fired the BLS commissioner on August 1, 2025 for processing the data correctly .
That reaction was widely condemned as “firing the messenger,” with economists and former Trump appointees warning that politicizing data destroys trust in U.S. economic statistics .
Bottom Line
There’s no mystery here: the administration systematically undermines data integrity.
-
Cuts professional statisticians.
-
Guts statistical agencies by firing or encouraging attrition of analysts.
-
Publicly attacks experts when data doesn’t suit him, branding them liars or dismissing them as “stupid.”
-
Removes independent oversight by firing agency heads like McEntarfer.
Everything about this debacle—from misreading complexity to punishing agencies that do understand—boils down to one person. There is—and can be—no excuse or blame-shifting. The erosion of trust in government numbers is Trump’s doing, and his alone.
Sources you can link directly:
-
Essential timeline and firing of McEntarfer:
-
Evidence of moderation, revisions, and data shortfalls:
-
Broader statistical agency staffing crisis and data censorship:
No comments:
Post a Comment