07 August 2025

Trump's use of War Powers Act and Rhetoric has consequences.

If They’re Combatants, Then Geneva Applies—You Can’t Have It Both Ways

You can’t wage war with one hand and then claim it’s just “administrative detention” with the other.

With Donald Trump once again invoking emergency war powers and the grotesque “Alligator Alcatraz” facility coming online in Florida, we’ve reached a boiling point: Migrants, asylum seekers, and ICE detainees are being treated, spoken about, and even paraded publicly like enemy combatants. (And as an aside - the same applies in Gaza).

So here’s the question:

If the U.S. government is treating these individuals as combatants in a war, doesn’t that make them subject to the protections of the Geneva Conventions?

The answer? It’s not a definitive “no.” In fact, there’s a powerful case to be made that it’s “yes”—especially in the court of public opinion.

Geneva: Not Just for Uniformed Soldiers

The Third Geneva Convention covers the treatment of Prisoners of War (POWs)—those captured during armed conflict. It mandates:

Humane treatment
No torture
Access to food, water, and medical care
Protection from humiliation and degrading acts

And crucially, Common Article 3 applies to all individuals caught up in a conflict—even internal ones. It prohibits:

“Violence to life and person, in particular murder of all kinds, mutilation, cruel treatment and torture… outrages upon personal dignity, in particular humiliating and degrading treatment.”

Sources:

👉 https://www.icrc.org/en/law-and-policy/detention

👉 https://www.cvt.org/wp-content/uploads/immigration_detention_report_120p_06242021.pdf

They’re Being Called Combatants. That Counts.

Let’s be clear: While traditional legal interpretations may say ICE detainees aren’t “combatants,” the Trump administration’s rhetoric—and actions—say otherwise.

These migrants are being labeled as “invaders,” “illegals,” and “threats to national security.”
Trump explicitly refers to his immigration crackdown in military terms—a “war on the border.”
The Alligator Alcatraz facility is designed like a wartime prison camp, complete with militarized guards, barbed wire, and public declarations of “zero tolerance.”

You don’t get to militarize your language, invoke war powers, and create wartime visuals—and then pretend it’s all just standard administrative procedure.

The public hears “war.” The public sees “prisoners.” And that’s where the Geneva Conventions come into play—not just in courtrooms, but in the court of public opinion.

Alligator Alcatraz coverage:

👉 https://www.reuters.com/world/us/trump-play-up-alligator-alcatraz-deportations-florida-ahead-bill-deadline-2025-07-01/

Legal Reality vs. Political Optics

Sure, the legal argument may be tough to win in court—Geneva applies only to parties in armed conflict, with established combatant status.

But this fight isn’t just legal. It’s moral. It’s visual. And it’s already playing out across TikTok, Reddit, and X (formerly Twitter).

Here’s what matters:

Geneva doesn’t require that combatants wear uniforms or be part of a regular army—Common Article 3 applies in non-international conflicts too.
If Trump says there’s a “war,” and if he uses war powers to justify detention, then he’s framing this as a conflict.
And that opens the door to argue that Geneva obligations are triggered.

If it looks like war, sounds like war, and is enforced like war—Geneva rules apply.

The ACLU and Congress Are Already Sounding the Alarm

Human rights organizations and members of Congress are already treating this as a human rights emergency:

ACLU: “A direct assault on humanity, dignity, and the constitutional protections we all share.”

👉 https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/president-trumps-visit-to-alligator-alcatraz-detention-facility-highlights-floridas-descent-into-state-sponsored-cruelty
Congressional lawsuit over blocked access to ICE facilities:

👉 https://www.live5news.com/2025/07/31/12-members-congress-sue-trump-administration-ensure-access-ice-detention-centers/

And now the public is watching—and documenting. #AlligatorAlcatraz is trending. Photos are leaking. Detainees are being described as prisoners in a wartime scenario. Whether the U.S. government likes it or not, the narrative has already moved beyond legal nuance.

So What’s the Play Here?

We lean into the contradiction. If this is a “war,” then international war rules apply. That means Geneva. That means no torture, no degrading conditions, no cages in swamps.

And if Geneva doesn’t apply? Then Trump’s “war” powers collapse like a cardboard gator. You can’t have it both ways.

Either:

You’re treating these people as enemy combatants—and Geneva applies

OR
You’re making war-like threats against civilians—and that’s even worse

Final Thought: Public Opinion Is the New Tribunal

The courts may waffle. Congress may stall. But the public square is already holding court—and the verdict is coming in loud, viral, and unforgiving.

Trump wants to win votes by declaring a war on migrants?

Fine. Then we declare that those people—those human beings—are entitled to Geneva protections and everything that comes with them. And if the U.S. fails to deliver? It stands in violation of both its own Constitution and international law.

Sources

Geneva Convention principles:

👉 https://www.icrc.org/en/law-and-policy/detention

👉 https://www.cvt.org/wp-content/uploads/immigration_detention_report_120p_06242021.pdf
Alligator Alcatraz news:

👉 https://www.reuters.com/world/us/trump-play-up-alligator-alcatraz-deportations-florida-ahead-bill-deadline-2025-07-01/
ACLU condemnation:

👉 https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/president-trumps-visit-to-alligator-alcatraz-detention-facility-highlights-floridas-descent-into-state-sponsored-cruelty
Congressional lawsuit:

👉 https://www.live5news.com/2025/07/31/12-members-congress-sue-trump-administration-ensure-access-ice-detention-centers/
Hamdan v. Rumsfeld legal precedent:

👉 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamdan_v._Rumsfeld

General Advocacy & Legal Rights

#HumanRights
#GenevaConventions
#DueProcess
#InternationalLaw
#RuleOfLaw
#ICCPR
#CivilLiberties

Immigration & Detention Context

#ImmigrationJustice
#EndDetention
#AsylumSeekers
#MigrantRights
#ICEAbuse
#ImmigrationPolicy
#BorderCrisis

Political Commentary

#EmergencyPowers
#AlligatorAlcatraz
#TrumpWarPowers
#StateOfException
#WarOnMigrants
#PowerAndAccountability

Public Awareness & Action

#ExposeTheCamps
#JusticeForDetainees
#RightsNotRaids
#NoHumanIsIllegal
#DemandAccountability
#StopTheAbuse

Professor Sabena's Blog